CO129-325 - Public Offices & Others - 1904 — Page 594

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

591

MO

ubwg

03

country it has been laid down that if the pilot is in charge he is undoubtedly the responsible man. Knowing your kindly interest in anything which appertains to an injustice being unwarrantably committed, the Guild make an earnest appeal to you that you will cause full inquiry to be made into the case referred to, and they hope that this will ultimately lead to Captain S. Bell Smith's conviction being quashed through your powerful influence. If it is allowed to stand, it will mean the perpetuation of a very serious injustice. I am also to ask if you would kindly inform them under what Statute a Marine Court such as that at Hong Kong is constituted, as the Guild are not aware of a similar Court elsewhere.

The Guild, in communicating with the Colonial Office previous to the retirement of the late Harbour-Master at Hong Kong, strongly urged that such a post would most suitably be filled by a gentleman of lengthy experience in the Merchant Service, who would then be familiar with all the various details concerning the great shipping trade carried on at that port, and would be able to deal effectively and efficiently with the many emergencies which arise in connection with merchant ships.

Merchant Captains and Officers who are charged with offences in connection with their duties on board ship have a right to be judged by those who are thoroughly acquainted with these duties by practical experience. The systems and methods prevailing in the Royal Navy are quite different to those in the Merchant Service. The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in the early part of this year, after a communication from the Guild, caused a Despatch to be sent to Shanghai, that in cases in the High Court affecting merchant vessels, there should at least be one merchant captain as an Assessor. In the Marine/

Edit History

2026-06-02 03:44:30 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
591MOubwg03country it has been laid down that if the pilot is in charge he is undoubtedly the responsible man. Knowing your kindly interest in anything which appertains to an injustice being unwarrantably committed, the Guild make an earnest appeal to you that you will cause full inquiry to be made into the case referred to, and they hope that this will ultimately lead to Captain S. Bell Smith's conviction being quashed through your powerful influence. If it is allowed to stand, it will mean the perpetuation of a very serious injustice. I am also to ask if you would kindly inform them under what Statute a Marine Court such as that at Hong Kong is constituted, as the Guild are not aware of a similar Court elsewhere.The Guild, in communicating with the Colonial Office previous to the retirement of the late Harbour-Master at Hong Kong, strongly urged that such a post would most suitably be filled by a gentleman of lengthy experience in the Merchant Service, who would then be familiar with all the various details concerning the great shipping trade carried on at that port, and would be able to deal effectively and efficiently with the many emergencies which arise in connection with merchant ships.Merchant Captains and Officers who are charged with offences in connection with their duties on board ship have a right to be judged by those who are thoroughly acquainted with these duties by practical experience. The systems and methods prevailing in the Royal Navy are quite different to those in the Merchant Service. The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in the early part of this year, after a communication from the Guild, caused a Despatch to be sent to Shanghai, that in cases in the High Court affecting merchant vessels, there should at least be one merchant captain as an Assessor. In the Marine/
Baseline (Original)
!591MOubwg03country it has been laid down that if the pilot is in charge he is undoubtedly the responsible man. Knowing your kindly interest in anything which appertains to an injustice being unwarrantably committed, the Guild make an earnest appeal to you that you will cause full inquiry to be made into the case referred to, and they hope that this will ultimately lead to Captain S.Bell Smith's conviction being quashed through your powerful influence. If it is allowed to stand, it will mean the perpetuation of a very serious injustice. I am also to ask if you would kindly inform them under what Statute a Marine Court such as that at Hong Kong is constituted, as the Guild are not aware of a similar Court else-where.The Guild, in communicating with the Colonial Office previous to the retirement of the late Harbour-Master at Hong Kong, strongly urged that such a post would most suitably be filled by a gentle- man of lengthy experience in the Merchant Service, who would then be familiar with all the various details concerning the great ship- ping trade carried on at that port, and would be able to deal ef- fectively and efficiently with the many emergencies which ariseMerchant Captains and Officers in connection with merchant ships. who are charged with offences in connection with their duties on board ship have a right to be judged by those who are thoroughly acquainted with these duties by practical experience. The sys-tems and methods prevailing in the Royal Navy are quite different to those in the Merchant Service. The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in the early part of this year, after a communica- tion from the Guild, caused a Despatch to be sent to Shanghai, that in cases in the High Court affecting merchant vessels, there should at least be one merchant captain as an Assessor. In the Marine/
2026-06-02 03:44:30 · Baseline
View content

!

591

MO

ubwg

03

country it has been laid down that if the pilot is in charge he

is undoubtedly the responsible man. Knowing your kindly interest

in anything which appertains to an injustice being unwarrantably

committed, the Guild make an earnest appeal to you that you will

cause full inquiry to be made into the case referred to, and

they hope that this will ultimately lead to Captain S.Bell Smith's

conviction being quashed through your powerful influence. If it is allowed to stand, it will mean the perpetuation of a very serious injustice. I am also to ask if you would kindly inform them under what Statute a Marine Court such as that at Hong Kong is constituted, as the Guild are not aware of a similar Court else-

where.

The Guild, in communicating with the Colonial Office previous to the retirement of the late Harbour-Master at Hong Kong, strongly urged that such a post would most suitably be filled by a gentle- man of lengthy experience in the Merchant Service, who would then be familiar with all the various details concerning the great ship- ping trade carried on at that port, and would be able to deal ef- fectively and efficiently with the many emergencies which arise

Merchant Captains and Officers

in connection with merchant ships.

who are charged with offences in connection with their duties on board ship have a right to be judged by those who are thoroughly acquainted with these duties by practical experience.

The sys-

tems and methods prevailing in the Royal Navy are quite different to those in the Merchant Service. The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in the early part of this year, after a communica- tion from the Guild, caused a Despatch to be sent to Shanghai, that in cases in the High Court affecting merchant vessels, there should at least be one merchant captain as an Assessor. In the

Marine/

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.